CHAPTER XXVII SYMBOLIC REPRESENTATION OF GENERAL ALTERNATING WAVES 259. The vector representation, A — a'^ -{- ja^'^ = a (cos d -\- j sin 6) of the alternating wave, A = tto cos {(f) — 6) apphes to the sine wave only. The general alternating wave, however, contains an infinite series of terms, of odd frequencies, A = Aicos( 0- ^i) + ^3 cos (3 (^ - 63) + As cos (5 <^ - ^5) + thus cannot be directly represented by one complex vector quantity. The replacement of the general wave by its equivalent sine wave, as before discussed, that is, a sine wave of equal effective intensity and equal power, while sufficiently accurate in many cases, completely fails in other cases, especially in circuits con- taining capacity, or in circuits containing periodically (and in synchronism with the wave) varying resistance or reactance (as alternating arcs, reaction machines, synchronous induction motors, oversaturated magnetic circuits, etc.). Since, however, the individual harmonics of the general alter- nating wave are independent of each other, that is, all products of different harmonics vanish, each term can be represented by a complex symbol, and the equations of the general wave then are the resultants of those of the individual harmonics. This can be represented symbolically by combining in one formula symbolic representations of different frequencies, thus, A = 22n-i(a„i+i„a„ii),^ 1 1 The index 2n — 1 in the S sign denotes that only the odd values of n are considered. If the wave contained even harmonics, the even vahies of n would also be considered, and the index in the 2 sign would be n. 379 380 ALTERNATING-CURRENT PHENOMENA where jn = V - 1, and the index of the j„ merely denotes that the j's of differ- ent indices, n, while algebraically identical, physically represent different frequencies, and thus cannot be combined. The general wave of e.m.f. is thus represented by E = 2:2n-i(e„i4-j„e„ii), 1 the general wave of current by 1 If Zi = r -^ j (x„, -{- xo -\- Xc) is the impedance of the fundamental harmonic, where Xm is that part of the reactance which is proportional to the frequency (inductance, etc.), ^ Xo is that part of the reactance which is independent of the frequency (mutual inductance, synchronous motion, etc.). Xc is that part of the reactance which is inversely propor- tional to the frequency (capacity, etc.). The impedance for the nth harmonic is + jn (nxr^ + a^o + -^ ) This term can be considered as the general symbolic expression of the impedance of a circuit of general wave-shape. Ohm's law, in symbolic expression, assumes for the general alternating wave the form 7 = ^or, S2n-i(t„i +j„^„ii) = Ssn-i E r -{- Jn [^nxm + Xo + — j = IZ or, 22n-i (e„i -\-jner}^) = S2n-i l^r + jn {rixm + 3^0 + ^) ] Kj'n "T" Jnt'n ) , 1 \ n I ?„' -\-Jnln^ The symbols of multiplication and division of the terms, E, I, Z, GENERAL ALTERNATING WAVES 381 thus represent, not algebraic operation, but multiplication and division of corresponding terms of E, I, Z, that is, terms of the same index, ??., or, in algebraic multiplication and division of the series, E, I, all compound terms, that is, terms containing two different n's, vanish. 260. The effective value of the general wave, a = A 1 cos (0 - ^i) + A3 cos (3 0 - ^3) + ^5 cos (5 0 - ^2) +• • is the square root of the sum of mean squares of individual har- monics, A = VmITTaT+^TTTTT}". Since, as discussed above, the compound terms of two different indices, n, vanish, the absolute value of the general alternating wave. A Vo 1 Q» ~T" Jnttn 1 On ^ JnOn is thus. which offers an easy means of reduction from symbolic to absolute values. Thus, the absolute value of the e.m.f., E = S2.-i(e„i+j„e„u)^ 1 is E = ^/22n-i(e/ + e„u2)^ the absolute value of the current, 1 is / = ^/S2.-1(^/ + ZV^'). 261. The double frequency power (torque, etc.) equation of the general alternating wave has the same symbolic expression as with the sine wave, 382 ALTERNATING-CURRENT PHENOMENA P = [EI] = Pi + jP^ = [Ely -{- j[Ei]j 1 1 where Pi = [Ely = i:2n-i(e„ii„i + e^iHV^), 1 1 J The jn enters under the summation sign of the reactive or "wattless power," P', so that the wattless powers of the different harmonics cannot be algebraically added. Thus, The total "true power'' of a general alternating-cihrrent circuit is the algebraic sum of the poioers of the individual harmonics. The total "reactive power" of a general alternating-curremt circuit is not the algebraic, but the absolute sum of the wattless powers of the individual harmonics. Thus, regarding the reactive power as a whole, in the general alternating circuit no distinction can be made between lead and lag, since some harmonics may be leading, others lagging. The apparent power, or total volt-amperes, of the circuit is P, = EI = JX2n-i{ej" + e„i022n-i(4i' + *V^'). \ 1 1 The power-factor of the circuit is, P^ 1 P =w = \ 1 1 The term "inductance factor," however, has no meaning any more, since the reactive powers of the different harmonics are not directly comparable. The quantity go = Vl — p^ , ,.,..„ , . reactive power has no physical sigmncance, and is not . , , : total apparent power GENERAL ALTERNATING WAVES 383 The term pi " IP iiy 1 p 1I7 1 M=f''-7 ^7 1 J where ^" = ^ EI ' consists of a series of inductance factors, q„, of the individual harmonics. As a rule, if g^ = S2n-ig(„2^ 1 p' + 9' < 1, for the general alternating wave, that is, q differs from qo = Vl - p'. The complex quantity, V = S. = ^-^ JiiL±MIl ^ Pa EI EI _ J 1 Ji2n-i (en'' + e„ii') 22 n- 1 (^•„l' + ^•„ll') \ 1 1 = P -\- 22n-lj„g„^ 1 takes in the circuit of the general alternating wave the same position as power-factor and inductance factor with the sine wave. p y = 77 may be called the "circuit-factor." ■la It consists of a real term, p, the power-factor, and a series of imaginary terms, in^n, the inductance factors of the individual harmonics. The absolute value of the circuit-factor. as a rule, is < 1. 384 ALTERNATING-CURRENT PHENOMENA - 262. Some applications of this symbolism will explain its mechanism and its usefulness more fully. First Example. — Let the e.m.f., 5 1 be impressed upon a circuit of the impedance, Z = r^jr. [nxr. - ^) = 10+ i„(lOn- ^) that is, containing resistance, r, inductive reactance Xm and con- densive reactance Xc in series. Let eii = 720 ei^i = - 540 egi = 283 63^^ = 283 e,' = - 104 65^' = - 138 or, ei = 900 tan Oi = 0.75 63 = 400 tan 03 = -1.0 65 = 173 tan 05 = - 1-33 It is thus in symbolic expression, Zi = 10 - 80 ji zi = 80.6 Zz =10 23 = 10.0 Z, = 10 + 32 is 25 = 33.5, and e.m.f., E = (720 - 540 JO + (283 + 283 js) + ( - 104 - 138 J5), or, absolute, E = 1000, and current, J _E _ 720 - 540 ii 283 + 283 jz - 104 - 138 js l~ Z~ 10 ~ 80 ii "*" 10 "^ 10 + 32 J5 = (7.76 + 8.04ii) + (28.3 + 28.3i3) + ( - 4.86 + 1.73 js) or, absolute, 7 = 41.85, of which is of fundamental frequency, 7i = 11.15 of triple frequency, /3 = 40 GENERAL ALTERNATING WAVES 385 of quintuple frequency, U = 5.17. The total apparent power of the circuit is Pa = EI = 41,850. The true power of the circuit is, pi = [Ely = 1240 + 16,000 + 270, = 17,510, the reactive power, jP^ = j[EI]> = - 10,000 ji + 850 is; thus, the total power, P = 17,510 - 10,000 ji + 850 ja. That is, the reactive power of the first harmonic is leading, that of the third harmonic zero, and that of the fifth harmonic lagging. 17,510 = Pr, as obvious. The circuit-factor is, ., P [EI] . Pa EI = 0.418 - 0.239 ji + 0.0203 i5, or, absolute, V = VO.4182 + 0.2392 + 0.02032. = 0.482. The power-factor is p = 0.418. The inductance factor of the first harmonic is qi = — 0.239, that of the third harmonic 53 = 0, and of the fifth harmonic 55 = + 0.0203. Considering the waves as replaced by their equivalent sine waves, from the sine wave formula, p^ + qo^ = 1, the inductance factor would be, Qo = 0.914, and the phase angle, tan d = ^ = ^-^I^ = 2.8, 6 = 65.4°, p 0.418 ' 25 386 ALTERNATING-CURRENT PHENOMENA giving apparently a very great phase displacement, while in reality, of the 41.85 amp. total current, 40 amp. (the current of the third harmonic) are in phase with their e.m.f. We thus have here a case of a circuit with complex harmonic waves which cannot be represented by their equivalent sine waves. The relative magnitudes of the different harmonics in the wave of current and of e.m.f. differ essentially, and the circuit has simultaneously a very low power-factor and a very low inductance factor; that is, a low power-factor exists without corresponding phase displacement, the circuit-factor being less than one-half. Such circuits, for instance, are those including alternating arcs, reaction machines, synchronous induction motors, react- ances with over-saturated magnetic circuit, high potential lines in which the maximum difference of potential exceeds the corona voltage, polarization cells and in general electrolytic conductors above the dissociation voltage of the electrolyte, etc. Such cir- cuits cannot correctly, and in many cases not even approximately, be treated by the theory of the equivalent sine waves, but re- quire the symbolism of the complex harmonic wave. 263. Second Example. — A condenser of capacity, Co = 20 mf. is connected into the circuit of a 60-cycle alternator giving a wave of the form, e = E{cos 4> - 0.10 cos 3 0 - 0.08 cos 5 0 + 0.06 cos 7 4>), or, in symbolic expression, E = e(li - O.IO3 - O.O85 + O.O67). The synchronous impedance of the alternator is Zo = n -\- jntixo = 0.3 + 5 njn. What is the apparent capacity, C, of the condenser (as calcu- lated from its terminal volts and amperes) when connected directly with the alternator terminals, and when connected thereto through various amounts of resistance and inductive reactance? The condensive reactance of the condenser is 10'' ^c = o fn = 132 ohms, ^TTjCo or, in symbolic expression, _ . a:^ _ _ 132 . GENERAL ALTERNATING WAVES 387 Let Zi = r -\- j„nx = impedance inserted in series with the condenser. The total impedance of the circuit is then Z 132\ Xr , s . /r ■, 132\ = Zo + Zi-i„^ = (0.3 +r) +Jn([5 + a:]n---^) The current in the circuit is _ E _ V 1 QA ~ Z~ ^ L(0.3 + r) +j (x - 127) (0.3 + r) + js (3 x - 29) 0.08 0.06 0.0(3 -| "^ (0.3 + r) -77(7a; + 16.1)J' (0.3 + r) +i5(5a;-1.4) ^ (0.3 + r) - jr (7 a; + 16.1). and the e.m.f. at the condenser terminals, xj r 132 Ji 4.4i (0.3 + r) +ii(a;- 127) (0.3+r)+i3(3a;-29) 2.11i5 , 1.13i7 -] "^ fO.3 4- r) + 77 (7 a; 4- 16.1) J' (0.3 + r) -\-j,{6x - 1.4) ^ (0.3 + r) +i7(7a;+ 16.1) thus the apparent condensive reactance of the condenser is E, Xi = and the apparent capacity, Xi = -^' c= "> 2irfXi (a) X = 0: Resistance, r, in series with the condenser. Re- duced to absolute values it is 1 0.01 0.0064 0.0036 J_ _ (0.3+r) + 16129^(0.3+0 + 841 ^ (0.3+r) + 1.96 ^ (0.3+r) + 259 xi^ ~ 16129 19.4 4.45 1.28 (0.3+r)2+16129 + (0.3+r) + 841 + (0.3+r) + 1.96 "^ (0.3+r)2+259 (6) r = 0 : Inductive reactance, a;, in series with the condenser. Reduced to absolute values it is 1 , 0-01 , 0.0064 1 0.09+(x-127)''^0.09+(3x-29)''^0.09+(5j-1.4)'' xi2 ~ 16129 19.4 4.45 0.09+(x -127)2 + 0.09+(3x -29)2 +0.09+ (5 X- 1.4)''"^ 0.0036 0.09+ (7 x+ 16.1)2 1.28 0.09+ (7 .1+16.1)= 388 AL TERN A TING-C URREN T PHENOMENA From — ^ are derived the values of apparent capacity, Xi C and plotted in Fig. 189 for values of r and x respectively varying from 0 to 22 ohms. As seen, with neither additional resistance nor reactance in series to the condenser, the apparent capacity with this generator wave is 84 mf., or 4.2 times the true capacity, and gradually de- creases with increasing series resistance, to C = 27 m.f. = 1.35 times the true capacity at r = 13.2 ohms, or one-tenth the true capacity reactance. With r = 132 ohms, or with an additional resistance equal to the condensive reactance, C = 20.2 mf. or only CAPACITY Co = 20mf IN CIRCUIT OF GENERATOR £"=£ (1-0.l-O.O8-U.UCi) OF IMPEDANCE Zo-=0.3-5njn WITH RESISTANCE T (I) OR REACTANCE X (II) IN SERIES < r C: 100 h 90 \ o 80 V s. < I 70 \ ^ \, c 60 ^ K / / \ 50 \ N / \ 40 V II ■*-v ^ ^ V =^>^ 30 ■"* Co RESI STA> CE 7 ^ REAC TANC EX _ 20 10 ; II 2 3 4. I i 1 9 10 1 1 1 2 1 i 1 4 15 1 S 1 7 1 8 1 3 2 0 0 Fig. 180. one per cent, in excess of the true capacity, Co, and at r = co , C = 20 mf. or the true capacity. With reactance, x, but no additional resistance, r, in series, the apparent capacity, C, rises from 4.2 times the true capacity at a; = 0, to a maximum of 5.03 times the true capacity, or C ~ 100. G mf. at a; = 0.28, the condition of resonance of the fifth harmonic, then decreases to a minimum of 27 mf., or 35 per cent, in excess of the true capacity, rises again to 60.2 mf., or 3.01 times the true capacity at a: = 9.67, the condition of resonance with the third harmonic, and finally decreases, reaching 20 mf., or the true capacity at re = 132, or an inductive reactance equal to the condensive reactance. GENERAL ALTERNATING WAVES 389 It thus follows that the true capacity of a condenser cannot even approximately be determined by measuring volts and amperes if there are any higher harmonics present in the generator wave, except by inserting a very large resistance or reactance in series to the condenser. 264. Third Exam/pie. — An alternating-current generator of the wave, ^0 = 2000 [li + 0.123 - 0.235 - O.ISt], and of synchronous impedance, Zo = 0.3 + 5 njn, feeds over a line of impedance, Zi = 2 + 4 njn, a synchronous motor of the wave, El = 2250 [(cos e - ji sin 6) + 0.24 (cos ^ 6 - jz sin 3 6)], and of synchronous impedance, Z2 = 0.3 + 6 njn. The total impedance of the system is then, Z = Zo + Zi + Z2 = 2.6 + 15 njn, thus the current, J _ Eg — El . ~ z _ 2000 - 2250 cos g+ 2250 ji sing 240 -540 cos 3^+540^3 sin 3 g 2.6+15ji + 2.6-45J3 _ " 460 _ 260 2.6 +75 is ~ 2.6 + 105^7 = (fli^ - iitti") + {a,^ - jsa,'') + (agi - j,a,'') + (a^i - jyay^; where ai^ = 22.5 - 25.2 cos d + 146 sin 6, agi = 0.306 - 0.69 cos 3 0 + 11.9 sin 3 d, at' = 0.213, a^i = - 0.061, ai^i = 130 - 146 cos 9 - 25.2 sin 6, 11 _ i — as" = - 6.12, 07" = - 2.48, or, absolute, 390 ALTERNATING-CURRENT PHENOMENA first harmonic, third harmonic, ^3 = vWM- as , fifth harmonic, as = 6.12, seventh harmonic, a-! = 2.48, I = Vai' + as^ + as^ + ay^; while the total current of higher harmonics is Iq = Vas^ + ae^ + ay^ The true input of the synchronous motor is Pi = [EJY = (2250 ail cos ^+2250 ai^^sin 6) + (540 a^^ cos 3 ^ + 540 as^sin 3 6 = Pi' + Ps' Pi^ = 2250 (ail cos 6 + ai" sin d), is the power of the fundamental wave, Ps^ = 540 {as' cos 3 ^ + 03" sin 3 6), the power of the third harmonic. The fifth and seventh harmonics do not give any power, since they are not contained in the synchronous motor wave. Sub- stituting now different numerical values for 6, the phase angle between generator e.m.f. and synchronous motor counter e.m.f., corresponding values of the. currents, /, Jo, and the powers, P^, Pi^, Ps', are derived. These are plotted in Fig. 190 with the total current, I, as abscissas. To each value of the total current, /, correspond two values of the total power, P^, a positive value plotted as Curve I — synchronous motor — and a negative value plotted as Curve II — alternating-current generator — . Curve III gives the total current of higher frequency, 7o, Curva IV the difference between the total current and the current of fundamental frequency, I — 7i, in percentage of the total current, /, and V the power of the third harmonic, Ps', in percentage of the total power, P^. Curves III, IV, and V correspond to the positive or synchron- ous motor part of the power curve, P^. As seen, the increase of GENERAL ALTERNATING WAVES 391 current due to the higher harmonics is small, and entirely dis- appears at about 180 amp. The power of the third harmonic is positive, that is, adds to the power of the synchronous motor % I PI 240 7 r > N 210 6 \ y y \ 180 5 \ :a / > \ 150 4 \ / / 120 3 > V / \ 90 2 s ::n lo \ 20 60 1 / •^ H ^ i^ 10 30 "•^^ * 0 1 H ^ ■n~ ■^ ■^ 7l 0 0 X V^ A / -30 \ ^v. "~T~ / -60 1 2 \ 0 6 ) f 0 1 AMPERES/ » 120 1' 0 1 )0 \i ffl 2 M 220 2 to 2 30 i iO -90 \ -120 N \ -150 \ v. -180 \, / -210 \ / -240 v^ / -270 E, SYNCHRONOUS MOTOR = 2250 (COS. 0 + ji 3in.f?)H- ^ \ / -300 0.24(cos. 35+ja sin. 3d OPERATED FROM GENERATOR ^^0=2000 ( 1 + 0.12-0.23-0.13 OVER TOTAL IMPEDANCE \ \ J -330 ^s Jl^ -^ / -360 Z„ = 5 .6+1 5U -.. Fig. 190. — Synchronous motor. up to about 140 amp. or near the maximum output of the motor, and then becomes negative. It follows herefrom that higher harmonics in the e.m.f. waves of generators and synchronous motors do not represent a mere waste of current, but may contribute more or less to the output of 392 ALTERNATING-CURRENT PHENOMENA the motor. Thus at 75 amp. total current, the percentage of increase of power due to the higher harmonic is equal to the increase of current, or in other words the higher harmonics of current do work with the same efficiency as the fundamental wave. 265. Fourth Example. — In a small three-phase induction motor, the constants per delta circuit are primary admittance Y = 0.002 — 0.03 j, self-inductive impedance Zo = Zi = 0.6 + 2.4 j,: and a sine wave of e.m.f., eo = 110 volts, is impressed upon the motor. The power output, P, current input, Is, and power-factor, p, as function of the slip, s, are given in the first columns of the follow- ing table, calculated in the manner as described in the chapter on Induction Motors. To improve the power-factor of the motor and bring it to unity at an output of 500 watts, a condenser capacity is required giving 4.28 amp. leading current at 110 volts, that is, neglecting the power loss in the condenser, capacity susceptance 4.28 110 0.039. In this case, let Is = current input into the motor per delta cir- cuit at slip s, as given in the following table. The total current supplied by the circuit with a sine wave of impressed e.m.f. is /' = 7,-1-4.28 i, power current . . and hereirom the power-iactor = . , . -, given m the ^ total current second columns of the table. If the impressed e.m.f. is not a sine wave but a wave of the shape, ^0 = eo(li + 0.123 - 0.235 - 0.1347), to give the same output, the fundamental wave must be the same: eo = 110 volts, when assuming the higher harmonics in the motor as wattless, that is, Eo = llOi -1- 13.23 - 25.35 - 14.77 = eo + Eo\ GENERAL ALTERNATING WAVES 393 where E^^ = 13.23 - 25.35 - 14.77 = component of impressed e.m.f. of higher frequency. The effective value is E(, = 114.5 volts. The condenser admittance for the general alternating wave is Yc = 0.039 7ljn. Since the frequency of rotation of the motor is small com- pared with the frequency of the higher harmonics, as total impedance of the motor for these higher harmonics can be assumed the stationary impedance, and by neglecting the resist- ance we have Z^ = nj„(a;o + Xi) = 4.8 njn The exciting admittance of the motor, for these higher har- monics, is, by neglecting the conductance, 71 = _ ^ = - ^M n n and the higher harmonics of counter e.m.f., E^ = — ^• . 2 Thus we have, current input in the condenser, L - EoYc = + 4.28ii + 1.54 i3 - 4.93^5 - 4.02i7; high-frequency component of motor-impedance current, W ^ ■^ = - 0.92 i3 + 1.06 i5 + 0.44 Jt; high-frequency component of motor-exciting current, ^lyi = ---— = _ 0.07 i3 + O.OSis + 0.03 J7: thus, total high-frequency component of motor current, 7oi =|l -I- E^Y^ = - 0.99 i3 + 1.14 J5 + 0.47 iv, 394 ALTERNATING-CURRENT PHENOMENA and total current, without condenser, Io= Is + U = Is- 0.99 is + 1.14i5 + 0.47 jj, with condenser, I = h-i- lo' - Ic = Is + 4.28ii + 0.55 is - 3.79 J5 + 3.55 jV; and herefrom the power-factor. In the following table and in Fig. 191 are given the values of current and power-factor: I. With sine wave of e.m.f., of 110 volts, and no condenser. II. With sine wave of e.m.f., of 110 volts, and with condenser. III. With distorted wave of e.m.f., of 114.5 volts, and no condenser. IV. With distorted wave of e.m.f., of 114.5 volts, and with condenser. TABLE I. II. III. IV. s P Is /, P l' P h P / p 0.0 0 0.24+ d.lOj 3.1 7.8 1.2 20.0 3.5 6.6 5.2 4.4 0.01 160 1.73+ 3.16J 3.6 48.0 2.1 84.0 3.9 43.0 5.5 31.0 0.02 320 3.32+ 3.47i 4.8 69.0 3.4 97.2 5.1 64.0 6.1 54.0 0.035 500 5.16+ 4.28i 6.7 77.0 5.2 100.0 6.9 72.5 7.2 68.0 0.05 660 6.95+ 5.4i 8.8 79.0 7.0 98.7 8.9 76.0 8.6 77.0 0.07 810 8.77+ 7.3i 11.4 77.0 9.3 94.5 11.5 73.5 10.6 80.0 0.10 885 10.1 + 9.85i 14.1 71.5 11.5 87.0 14.2 68.0 12.6 77.0 0.13 900 10. 45 + 11. 45i 15.5 67.5 12.7 82.0 15.6 64.5 13 7 73.0 0.15 890 10.75 + 12.9 i 16.8 64.0 13.8 78.0 16.9 61.0 14.7 70.0 The curves II and IV with condenser are plotted in dotted lines in Fig. 191. As seen, even with such a distorted wave the current input and power-factor of the motor are not much changed if no condenser is used. When using a condenser in shunt to the motor, however, with such a wave of impressed e.m.f. the increase of the total current, due to higher-frequency currents in the con- denser, is greater than the decrease, due to the compensation of lagging currents, and the power-factor is actually lowered by the condenser, over the total range of load up to overload, and espe- cially at light load. Where a compensator or transformer is used for feeding the condenser, due to the internal self-inductance of the compensa- tor, the higher harmonics of current are still more accentuated, that is, the power-factor still more lowered. In the preceding the energy loss in the condenser and compen- sator and that due to the higher harmonics of current in the motor GENERAL ALTERNATING WAVES 395 has been neglected. The effect of this energy loss is a slight decrease of efficiency and corresponding increase of power-factor. The power produced by the higher harmonics has also been neglected; it may be positive or negative, according to the index AMPERES thre'e-ph'ase induction motor y 14 1 110 V 1 5LT SINE 1 WAVE, NO CONDENSER 1 1 1 1 /) 13 II III 10 VOLT SINE 1 1 -14.6' VOLrS D '/VAVE,CO^ 1 STORTED- DENSER 1 IDEN SER 3Efl_ / // 12 IV 14.6 VOL rs Di STOF TED WAV! . cc NDEh 0 ■/ U 8PE ED _<^ / / 10 100 ,-■ --■ —^ b; ^ !) 90 ^^ ■\\ ^ f / ^\ 8 80 / ^ ^ ->= y ^ i::^ ^: 7 70 / Vx- ^ ::C^ :^ ■'^ ■y ^"^ X G CO / r rv '/ A t ^ ■>^ ^^ 5 50 / i — ^ ^ \ii. ^ <\ /^ ^ 4 40 4\ ^^' '^v 3 30 r // ,-''' .^■^ 2 20 A ^' '"^ OUTPUT PER PHASE, 1 1 WA- TS. 1 10 (L 1( 0 2 K) 3 )0 400 500 1 6C 0 7 X) 8C « 9( K) 0 0 Fig. 191. of the harmonic, and the winding of the motor primary. Thus, for instance, the effect of the triple harmonic is negative in the quarter-phase motor, zero in the three-phase motor, etc.; alto- gether, however, the effect of these harmonics is usually small. SECTION VII POLYPHASE SYSTEMS