D. C. COMMUTATING MACHINES 171 All these windings are closed-circuit windings; that is, starting at any point, and following the armature conductor, the circuit returns into itself after passing all e.m.fs. twice in opposite direc- tion (thereby avoiding short circuit). An instance of an open- coil winding is shown in Fig. 84, a series-connected three-phase star winding similar to that used in the Thomson-Houston arc machine. Such open-coil windings, however, cannot be used in commutating machines. They are generally preferred in syn- chronous and in induction machines. FIG. 84. — Open-circuit three-phase series drum winding. 38. By leaving space between adjacent coils of these windings a second winding can be laid in between. The second winding can either be entirely independent from the first winding, that is, each of the two windings closed upon itself, or after passing through the first winding the circuit enters the second winding, and after passing through the second winding it reenters the first winding. In the first case the winding is called a double spiral winding (or multiple spiral winding if more than two windings are used), in the latter case a double reentrant winding (or 172 ELEMENTS OF ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING multiple reentrant winding). In the double spiral winding the number of coils must be even; in the double reentrant winding, odd. Multiple spiral and multiple reentrant windings can be either multiple or series wound; that is, each spiral can consist either of a multiple or of a series winding. Fig. 85 shows a double spiral multiple ring winding, Fig. 86 a double spiral multiple drum winding, Fig. 87 a double reentrant multiple drum winding. As seen in the double spiral or double reentrant multiple wind- ing, twice as many circuits as poles are in multiple. Thus such FIG. 85. — Multiple double spiral ring winding. windings are mostly used for large low-voltage machines, but as very few large direct-current generators are built nowadays, and alternating-current generation with synchronous converters usu- ally preferred, and as multiple spiral or reentrant windings are inconvenient in synchronous converters, their use has greatly decreased. 39. A distinction is frequently made between lap winding and wave winding. These are, however, not different types; but the wave winding is merely a constructive modification of the series drum winding with single-turn coil, as seen by comparing